Thursday, November 19, 2026

Mad Eden by Morgan Thomas

Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026--San Antonio

Although Mad Eden was named as a finalist for the Booker Prize, I really couldn't get into it and quit reading at about 27% of the way into the book.  It was so confusing.  The general background was about Ro and Liam, a couple living in a remote area of Florida in a decrepid cabin and with financial difficulties.  Both are transgender--Ro is mtf and Liam is ftm.  There are complications in their relationship.  Ro has figured out that she is autistic.  Having sex has not developed to a method that satisfies each of them.  And Ro, who works to assist  homeless individuals and families with children who are searching for how to find gender-confirming care, has committed herself and Liam (reluctantly) into an unoffical adoption of a young homeless ftm transgender kid named Quintin who is a first-year college student with emotional stress problems, is living as a male, and is ready to start taking testosterone as the beginning step of his physical transition.  Because of their strained financial situation, Quintin and his needs are really an impossible burden on Ro and Liam.  All of that sounds like the beginning of an interesting story.  But the author complicates it all in two ways:  1)  Mad Eden is the title of a book that Ro has read and parts of the book are interspersed within the story with no clear way of knowing why (at least as far as I got into the book).  2)  I got the impression that the author was writing the story as a disguised self-help guide to inform and actually help persons interested in finding gender-affirming care as a work-around against the laws in Florida, Texas, and elsewhere that allow any person assisting young people with such a need to be sued by any citizen who knows what they are doing; in other words, it feels a lot like a self-help book disguised as a novel.  Anyway, I just couldn't keep pushing myself to read further.  I put the book aside and read another book thinking I would try coming back to it.  But I just didn't want to do so.  It was a reading experience that was frustratingly confusing.  I don't understand why it became a finalist for the Booker Prize unless, since the Booker is a British prize, the panel members were fascinated by the details of how horrible the situation is in the US for transgender persons these days.   No rating, but I know it would be at 3 or below as a novel if I had kept going.

No comments:

Post a Comment