The Midnight Library by Matt Haig

Monday, July 6, 2026--San Antonio

In my opinion, the very popular book The Midnight Library by Matt Haig is not a good novel.  It has contradictions and and is not very logical (even if one believes in the theory it is based upon).  I spent most of my time reading it trying to determine why it was so popular.  But I think I know.  People may think they are reading a good novel, but instead they are reading a rather clever self-help book.  They overlook the problems with it as a novel and let the book guide themselves through analyzing their own lives.  They think about their own regrets.  They think about the dreams they have abaondoned.  They think about how unhappy they are rather than what they can do to improve their life experience.  The book guides the reader through the failures experienced by Nora that have led to her suicide effort.  It provides a framework for analyzing what her life might have been if she had made different choices along the way by actually temporarily living the alternative to see if it is better or not.  As she is doing that, the reader is likely reasoning through whether the alternative choices they might have made themselves and what would be good/what could go wrong under those circumstances.  By the end, the book is guiding the reader to make a decision about what they could do to better appreciate the life that they have have been living so far so that they can make the future better.  See, it is a fairly good self-help guide.  But as a novel, I give it only 3 stars out of 5.

We Could Be So Good by Cat Sebastian

Wednesday, July 1, 2026--San Antonio

We Could Be So Good by Cat Sebastian is a novel from 3 years ago that was recommended by the NY Times, NPR, and others.  It takes place in New York in the late 1950s and is the story of a bisexual man and a gay man, both 25 years old, who fall in love during that period when it was dangerous to be known to be gay.  It's also the story of men from two different classes of society.  Nick is a crime reporter of for a newspaper who grew up in a rough Brooklyn neighborhood in a lower middle class family of Italian immigrants.  Andy has attended a private residential school and is the son of the owner/publisher of the newspaper and a deceased mother who was an international war correspondent.  Andy has been tasked by his father to "learn the ropes" of the business by working as a reporter for a few months so he can take his father's place in the top position.  It's the story of two opposites becoming attracted to each other.  It starts by Andy noting that Nick is one of the best reporters on the staff and moving into a desk across from him so they can work together as reporters.  That leads to them becoming friends and Andy introducing Nick to his fiance, Emily.  The 3 of them become friends together.  But just before the wedding, the plans fall apart when Emily, in London for an extended stay to care for a dying relative, falls in love with a doctor.  Nick and Andy have become so close as colleagues and friends that Nick takes on the task of trying to support Andy in his time of devastation and need.  He even invites Andy, who has been living alone in his mother's old apartment,  to come and live with him in the guest room he has in his Brooklyn apartment.  Rather than leave him alone there, Nick takes Andy on one of his Sunday outings to meet his Italian family.  Andy hasn't ever felt he was part of a family since his mother had left his father when he was very young, so the visit gives him a glimpse of what being in a real family is like.  As time passes Nick realizes that he has always been attracted to Andy who also starts noticing that he is attracted to Nick and may be something different from being just a straight man.  The story is built around the hesitancy of either to accept what is happening between them and the ways this hesitancy keeps either from making a move on the other.  It's an up and down rollercoaster ride all the way to the end of the novel.  Nick has always been hesitant to let anyone get close enough to him to know he is gay and even distances himself from his family because the question is always raised of when he will find a nice girl and settle down.  Andy is more open and flexible in his thinking.  It just takes lots of baby steps for either of them to be able to realize what has really happened and to get over their fears about ruining their friendship by being honest and trusting with each other.  There are laughable points throughout the book, and it is a good story.  It seems very realistic for the time period it takes place except for one major complaint I have.  Why does the author have them casually using the word "queer" in desribing themselves?  It wasn't until the late 1980s into the 1990s that LGBTQ+ people made the move to take control of that word and use it proudly as a self-identifier; before that it was used only by heterosexuals as a slur (similar to the changes in the use of the "N" word slur against Blacks).  How did the author and editors not realize the homosexual and bisexual characters in this story would not have called themselves "Queers" in the 1950s?  I gave the book 4 stars out of 5. 

John of John by Douglas Stuart

Tuesday, June 30, 2026--San Antonio

I have read all 3 novels written by Douglas Stuuart including this, his latest, John of John.  All 3 have been very good books and each one has been different from the rest.  This one is set in a remote Scottish Island-- mostly in a corner of the island where only about 25 people still live.  Many homes have been abandoned over the years as people have moved away or died, but they are popular with tourists who buy them to use as vacation homes.  Almost everyone living full time in the community belongs to a pentacostal-type Presbyterian church that operates a lot like a cult.  It even has a curtain down the center of the sanctuary, and only those who have dedicated their lives to Christ can sit in the front portion.  Those who have not yet given their lives to Christ and, therefore, not been baptised must sit behind the curtain.  That cult-like us/them situation goes beyond the church, though.  The community leaders (all of whom are members of the church, work to influence those in the community to make the "right" decisions.  (It all works just like the Southern Baptist Church in my hometown worked to try to control everything related to everyone.)  John, the first of the title characters who goes by an abbreviation, Cal, of his middle name since his father uses John (and is the second of the Johns in the title), has left the village to attend an art school which was okayed only because it dealt with "proper" types of art like weaving which most of the families do in the community as a part of a co-op to sell "authentic" Scottish Island wools.  But Cal doesn't want to go home after finishing his degree because he doesn't fit in right there and knows that returning would involve his family and the community in trying to manage his life--have him carrying on the sheep farm with and after his father, helping take care of his aging grandmother, and marrying the woman his age who has been friends with him for years, etc.  It would be a trap.  But the "good" members of the church group have no problems trying to manipulate and force everyone into doing what they want them to do (also like my own church was).  The story involves Cal returning and facing all of these problems while rebelling against them to the extent that he can.  His mother left his father years ago and is living with his uncle (his father's brother) with whom she has several more children who are his half-siblings.  The father has never re-married, so he wants his son to take over the farm.  The whole community wants him to marry the girl who has been his friend for years.  But there are many secrets behind the stories of everyone and more developing as time passes.  It's a book that is fascinating to read and will make you feel like you have been there observing it all.  I gave the book 5 stars out of 5.

Remarkably Bright Creatures by Shelby Van Pelt

Wednesday, June 24, 2026--San Antonio

I read Remarkably Bright Creatures by Shlby Van Pelt only because I had 4 books on hold I was waiting to receive and had had finished one I had been reading.  This book became immediately available due to the library having a no-holds-weekend for everyone interested.  Although the story is interesting, I found it to be a rather soppy one and one which is overly filled with coincidences of missed/interrupted moments of communication that were critical points.  I have Netflix and had avoided watching the movie version of the book because I wasn't sure if it would be worthshile.  I won't see it now since I have read the book which I will not recommend to anyone who prefers well-written literature.  Main points:  1)  Elderly widow has no living relatives: husband died a couple of years ago, estranged brother just died, and her only son disappeared at sea at 18 years old.  2)  She works as a janitor at the local aquarium cleaning it after closing time in the evenings while "talking" to the various sea creatures.  3)  Young man was left by his mother at 7 years of age to live with his aunt and, although very intelligent, has been fired from jobs over and over again.  4)  After looking through a school yearbook, he becomes convinced that a man who is in several class photos there must be his father--a man who is now a very wealthy developer.  5)  He moves back to the town in Washington where his mother grew up trying to get an appointment to meet his "dad" and ask him to pay him the child support that was never received as he was growing up.  From there, it becomes a comedy of errors with several side stories along the way.  I gave the book 3 1/2 stars out of 5.

Whistler by Ann Parchett

Monday, June 22, 2026--San Antonio

Whistler by Ann Parchett is a slow-reveal novel that is one of the big hits of 2026.  It centers around an accident that took place about 40 years earlier and the effect it had on the lives of the members of the family of the two persons in the accident at that time and what happened to all the members of the family over time since then.  It also deals with the one of the common complications of family life back in the 70s and 80s--about how two gay men married women to try to "hide" their secret from society that wouldn't accept them as they were and the effects on them and others because of it.  It deals with two sisters who didn't feel totally accepted and integrated in the new family their mother created with a new husband and the two sons they had in that family.  It deals with how that distance between those two sisters and their family created a type of independence that in the long run protected them emotionally in various ways in life.  It deals with the loss that is felt when a beloved person disappears from one's life and how that siutation is handled.  It deals with the bravery and intelligence of a girl of only 7 years old who is confronted with a live-or-death situation.  It deals with wondering how one's life might have been different given a change in circumstances in the past.  It deals with the difficulties of being in love, but needing more in life.  And it deals with what happens when a loved one dies.  It deals with storytelling and the publishing of stories.  I gave the book 4 1/2 stars out of 5.

Star Shipped by Cat Sebastian

Saturday, June 20, 2026--San Antonio

Star Shipped by Cat Sebastian was just the book I needed this week--a well written book among the short list of the top books of 2026 so far by the NY Times and one filled with hillarious banter that kept me laughing aloud.  It was so good that I started limiting how much I would read each day so the book would last longer.  It's the story of the two main stars of a 7-year-long-running series set in space.  The stars seem to hate each other and have been carrying on with bitchy bantering for the run of the show.  One of the actors is from a very wealthy family and suffers from anxiety and OCD.  The other had an alcoholic mother who left him and he ended up living in foster homes.  He suffers from a sense of abandonment and a fear of not ever being loved enough.  As the anxious character approaches the end of the season (intending to leave it to try to revive an award-winning serious career that he had before), he begins to realize that he will miss his co-star he has had so many intimate scenes with over the years.  The book covers the summer break between the 7th and the 8th (upcoming) season.  The characters find themselves interacting more and more together. And the reactions of the fans of the show on social media add a special (funny) spice to the story.  I'll leave the deatils to the readers.  I gave the book 5 stars out of 5 (agreeing with the NY Times).

Yesteryear by Caro Claire Burke

Monday, June 15, 2026--San Antonio

Yesteryear by Caro Claire Burke has been among the most popular books of this year.  I read it only because it became available in unlimited supply from my library for one weekend--a download to my Kindle.  I cannot say that it was a pleasure to read it.  Why?  Because ALL of the characters except for Maeve, the delightful, happy, youngest daughter, were despicable people.  And my question is:  How can anyone find pleasure reading a story filled with such people?  The main protagonist is a woman who has grown up poor in a home with no father but has gotten a full-ride scholarship to Harvard.  She is a fundamentalist Christian, so being at Harvard is a challenge socially.  She meets and marries a man who has grown up in a wealthy family with national political ties.  Yet her husband is the youngest and the weekest of the sons in his family--spoiled rotten without any interest in applying himself to any type of real world task.  Because of this, the woman decides she must be the one to make their life work.  But problems develop and multiply.  She has to keep her husband happy by keeping him thinking he is as important to the endeavor as she is.  Her personality is mostly grim and demanding of others, so to be the social influencer she is becoming she must provide a false impression of her real self.  This book has all of the problems of the present times--corrupt politics, talk of a coming civil war, envy, jealousy, lying, cheating, broadcasts and social media "spinning" stories, etc.  I waded through the book to the end.  If I rate it on how pleasurable it was to read it, I would have to give it no more than 2 1/2 stars out of 5.  But this unpleasureable book was well constructed, so I will give it an overall rating of 3 1/2 stars out of 5.